Comments on: A History of Scotland http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html Thu, 22 Apr 2010 11:01:28 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Anonymous http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-78 Anonymous Sat, 17 Apr 2010 10:15:49 +0000 http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-78 This book is written as more of a story of Scotland than a history. It is well developed, interesting, captivating and exciting. Probably the finest history book I've ever read. Gives an incredible overview of Scotland, and explains why those Scots who have become expats love their country despite all of the problems they have had (Highland clearances). For anyone who has been to Scotland this is a great way to learn so much about the country, and their courageous and proud people. I recommend this very highly. An enthralling book to read. Rating: 5 / 5 This book is written as more of a story of Scotland than a history. It is well developed, interesting, captivating and exciting. Probably the finest history book I’ve ever read. Gives an incredible overview of Scotland, and explains why those Scots who have become expats love their country despite all of the problems they have had (Highland clearances). For anyone who has been to Scotland this is a great way to learn so much about the country, and their courageous and proud people. I recommend this very highly. An enthralling book to read.
Rating: 5 / 5

]]> By: J. Michael Showalter http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-77 J. Michael Showalter Sat, 17 Apr 2010 09:49:58 +0000 http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-77 This is simply put one of the best places to start an inquiry into Scottish history. <p>Allowing the comments of one of the other reviewers, this book might not answer EVERY question that one might have regarding all of the specifics of Scots history. As in any book that sets out to tell the whole history of a people in under five hundred pages, there are omissions and a little of opaquenesses. Setting this aside, both the original author and the updaters of this book have done a remarkable job putting together a history that is equally entertaining and enlightening. This book DOES do an adequate job illustrating all of the changes of power and intricacies that are necessary to understand the interrelation between England and Scotland and the Highland and Lowland populations. It is fair which is important. And it is just a fun read.....<p>Beyond this, obviously, this book raises additional questions regarding the history of Scotland that must be answered by additional reading. But, then again, this is a book that as an intitiation, makes one want to read more.<p>I highly recommend this book.... Rating: 5 / 5 This is simply put one of the best places to start an inquiry into Scottish history.

Allowing the comments of one of the other reviewers, this book might not answer EVERY question that one might have regarding all of the specifics of Scots history. As in any book that sets out to tell the whole history of a people in under five hundred pages, there are omissions and a little of opaquenesses. Setting this aside, both the original author and the updaters of this book have done a remarkable job putting together a history that is equally entertaining and enlightening. This book DOES do an adequate job illustrating all of the changes of power and intricacies that are necessary to understand the interrelation between England and Scotland and the Highland and Lowland populations. It is fair which is important. And it is just a fun read…..

Beyond this, obviously, this book raises additional questions regarding the history of Scotland that must be answered by additional reading. But, then again, this is a book that as an intitiation, makes one want to read more.

I highly recommend this book….
Rating: 5 / 5

]]> By: Anonymous http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-76 Anonymous Sat, 17 Apr 2010 06:51:19 +0000 http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-76 The book is full of history and appears balanced in view but has far too many references to things not documented. For someone who knows nothing about British royalty, Scots history and geography this is not the place to start. <p>There are many confusing references. I had trouble understanding what and who Argyle is, why you spell Stewart/Stuart two ways with seemingly interchangable spellings, and many many royalty/title related terms that are confusing (duke/earl/baron etc. what's the difference?). A glossary would help. Otherwise, keep a dictionary and a good map handy. <p>Also the successions and following who murdered whom needs more diagrams and what diagrams and maps there are should all be redrawn for clarity. Rating: 3 / 5 The book is full of history and appears balanced in view but has far too many references to things not documented. For someone who knows nothing about British royalty, Scots history and geography this is not the place to start.

There are many confusing references. I had trouble understanding what and who Argyle is, why you spell Stewart/Stuart two ways with seemingly interchangable spellings, and many many royalty/title related terms that are confusing (duke/earl/baron etc. what’s the difference?). A glossary would help. Otherwise, keep a dictionary and a good map handy.

Also the successions and following who murdered whom needs more diagrams and what diagrams and maps there are should all be redrawn for clarity.
Rating: 3 / 5

]]> By: Ray Granger http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-75 Ray Granger Sat, 17 Apr 2010 04:31:32 +0000 http://www.prochoicescotland.org/32-a-history-of-scotland.html#comment-75 history reads as if it were written for Scotchmen exclusively. Not enough bio data on figures that are introduced so there is no grounding .....also, I never fail to marvel at how many histories invariably allude to their first settlers encountering the "indigenous" people. Who are these people and how did they get there? How much of what they were transferred culturally? Geography tells us much about behaviour but is rarely considered when compiling pre-histories. Rating: 2 / 5 history reads as if it were written for Scotchmen exclusively. Not enough bio data on figures that are introduced so there is no grounding …..also, I never fail to marvel at how many histories invariably allude to their first settlers encountering the “indigenous” people. Who are these people and how did they get there? How much of what they were transferred culturally? Geography tells us much about behaviour but is rarely considered when compiling pre-histories.
Rating: 2 / 5

]]>